Short answer
Why there is more than one method
Each daily prayer has a time defined by the sun. PrayTimes.org, a widely used reference for the calculations, summarises the definitions like this:
- Fajr begins when the sky first starts to lighten at dawn.
- Dhuhr begins when the sun starts to decline after reaching its highest point.
- Asr begins when an object's shadow reaches a set multiple of its length, plus its shadow at noon.
- Maghrib begins soon after sunset.
- Isha begins when complete darkness has set in and no twilight remains.
Dawn and nightfall are defined by twilight, and each method picks an angle for them: how far below the horizon the sun must be for dawn to count as begun or for twilight to count as gone. As PrayTimes.org puts it, there are differing opinions on what angle to use for Fajr and Isha.
The Adhan documentation describes the effect in these terms: the Egyptian (19.5 degrees) and Singapore (20 degrees) conventions give an early Fajr, while ISNA, with 15 degrees, gives later Fajr and earlier Isha times.
The main methods and their angles
These are the conventions listed by PrayTimes.org, with the Fajr and Isha angles each one uses:
| Method | Fajr angle | Isha |
|---|---|---|
| Muslim World League | 18 | 17 |
| Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) | 15 | 15 |
| Egyptian General Authority of Survey | 19.5 | 17.5 |
| Umm al-Qura University, Makkah | 18.5 | 90 minutes after Maghrib (120 in Ramadan) |
| University of Islamic Sciences, Karachi | 18 | 18 |
| Institute of Geophysics, University of Tehran | 17.7 | 14 |
| Islamic Religious Council of Singapore | 20 | 18 |
PrayTimes.org also lists conventions used in France, Russia and by the Leva Research Institute in Qum. All angles are in degrees below the horizon.
Two things stand out. Umm al-Qura does not use an angle for Isha at all: it sets Isha at a fixed interval after Maghrib. The Adhan documentation also says its Tehran method calculates Maghrib from the sun reaching 4.5 degrees below the horizon rather than at sunset. Separately, PrayTimes.org says the Sunni view starts Maghrib at sunset, with a precautionary delay of 1 to 3 minutes, while the Shia view waits until the redness in the sky has passed overhead.
The documentation for Adhan, an open-source prayer time library, describes the practical effect of some of these. It also lists methods not in the table above, including ones for Dubai, Kuwait and Qatar, an approximation of the Diyanet method used in Turkey, and the Moonsighting Committee method, which uses 18 degree angles with seasonal adjustments. For North America it says ISNA can be used but that the Moonsighting Committee method is preferable.
Calculates the five daily prayer times on the phone, with alerts, a Qibla compass and the Qur'an.
Get it on Google PlayFree with a small banner ad on the Zakat, Monthly timetable, More and Settings screens only. One optional one-time purchase unlocks the memorisation companion and also removes the banner. There is no subscription.
Miqat works out prayer times on your phone from your location and the date. You can choose a calculation method, Standard or Hanafi Asr, a high-latitude rule and a per-prayer adjustment in minutes, which helps you match a local mosque timetable. Each place keeps its own settings.
Places where the angles stop working
PrayTimes.org says that at higher latitudes twilight may persist throughout the night during some months of the year, and the standard Fajr and Isha formulas then fail. It describes three alternatives:
- Middle of the night. The period from sunset to sunrise is divided into two halves, and Fajr and Isha are taken to be at midnight during the abnormal periods.
- One-seventh of the night. The night is divided into seven parts. Isha begins after the first seventh, and Fajr at the beginning of the seventh part.
- Angle-based. PrayTimes.org calls this an intermediate solution used by some recent calculators. The night is divided in proportion to the twilight angle. With a 15 degree Isha angle, for example, Isha begins at the end of the first quarter of the night.
The Adhan documentation recommends the one-seventh rule for locations above 48 degrees latitude, to prevent prayer times that would be difficult to perform, and says its Moonsighting Committee method applies it automatically at or above 55 degrees. Which rule your community uses is a local decision.
Small adjustments on top of the method
PrayTimes.org mentions a precautionary delay of 1 to 3 minutes for Maghrib in the Sunni view, and the Adhan documentation says its Dubai method adds 3 minute offsets to sunrise, Dhuhr, Asr and Maghrib. Some mosque timetables may add their own margins. If your app is consistently a minute or two off your mosque's timetable for one prayer, a margin like this may be the reason, and a per-prayer adjustment can match it.
How to choose
You do not need to pick a method on its merits. The practical steps are:
- Get your local mosque's printed or online timetable.
- Ask which method it uses, or compare a few days against the methods your app offers.
- Set your Asr preference. Our guide to Hanafi and Shafi'i Asr times explains the difference.
- If one prayer is still a minute or two off, add a per-prayer adjustment.
- Check again in a different season, because the gaps between methods can change through the year.
If your mosque's timetable is based on local observation rather than one of these methods, follow the mosque. When you are unsure which approach to follow, ask your imam or a scholar you trust. For finding the direction of prayer, see how to find the qibla direction.