Skip to content

Asr Time Hanafi vs Shafi'i - Why They Differ

In this guide
  1. The shadow rule in plain words
  2. Which is earlier
  3. How to check which one a timetable uses
  4. Choosing a setting

Short answer

The two Asr times come from two scholarly views on the length of a shadow. In the majority view, held by the Shafi'i, Maliki and Hanbali schools (and the Ja'fari school), Asr begins when an object's shadow equals its own height plus its shadow at noon, according to PrayTimes.org. In the Hanafi school, Asr begins when the shadow is twice the object's height plus its noon shadow. So the Hanafi Asr time is later. Prayer apps offer this as an Asr setting.

The shadow rule in plain words

Stand a stick upright in the sun. At midday, when the sun is highest, its shadow is at its shortest. This is called the noon shadow.

As the afternoon goes on, the sun drops and the shadow grows. Asr is defined by how long that shadow has become.

PrayTimes.org, a widely used reference for prayer time calculations, describes the two views:

  • Majority view (Shafi'i, Maliki, Ja'fari and Hanbali). Asr begins when the shadow's length equals the object's height plus its noon shadow.
  • Hanafi view. Asr begins when the shadow is twice the object's height plus its noon shadow.

Miqat: Prayer Times & Qibla

Calculates the five daily prayer times on the phone, with alerts, a Qibla compass and the Qur'an.

Get it on Google Play

Free with a small banner ad on the Zakat, Monthly timetable, More and Settings screens only. One optional one-time purchase unlocks the memorisation companion and also removes the banner. There is no subscription.

Miqat lets you choose Standard (Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanbali) or Hanafi Asr alongside your calculation method, a high-latitude rule and a per-prayer adjustment. Each place keeps its own settings, and times are calculated on your phone.

Which is earlier

The majority view gives the earlier time, because the shadow reaches one object length (plus its noon shadow) before it reaches two. The documentation for Adhan, an open-source prayer time library, describes its two madhab settings exactly that way: Shafi as "earlier Asr time" and Hanafi as "later Asr time".

Adhan's "Shafi" setting is its default. Because PrayTimes.org lists the Maliki, Ja'fari and Hanbali schools with the Shafi'i under the same rule, the label is a shorthand, not a statement that only Shafi'is use it.

How to check which one a timetable uses

If a timetable lists two Asr times, the earlier one matches the majority view and the later one the Hanafi view, since the Hanafi rule needs the longer shadow. The quickest way to know which one your mosque uses is to compare its printed Asr time with both settings in your app for the same day.

If your app's Asr time does not match your mosque, check in this order:

  1. Is the Asr setting the one your mosque uses?
  2. Is the location correct? A different city, even a nearby one, shifts every time.
  3. Does the mosque add a few minutes of margin? If so, a per-prayer adjustment can match it.

Asr is set by the shadow rule. PrayTimes.org lists the Fajr and Isha angles of each calculation method separately from the Asr rule, and the Adhan library likewise has a separate madhab setting for Asr. Our guide to prayer time calculation methods explains the angles.

Choosing a setting

Which view to follow is a question for your own school of thought, your local mosque and the scholars you trust. This page does not try to settle it. In practice, people often follow the Asr time printed by the mosque they attend, or ask their imam when they move to a new area.

If you are travelling, it is worth checking the local mosque's timetable when you arrive. For the direction of prayer when you are somewhere new, see how to find the qibla direction.

Sources

  1. Prayer Times Calculation, Asr - PrayTimes.org
  2. Calculation methods and madhab settings - Adhan library documentation

Search the site