Skip to content

Best First Move in Mancala

In this guide
  1. Why that pit works
  2. Why guides disagree about the "third pit"
  3. What to play after the extra turn
  4. Does going first win?
  5. Habits that follow from the rules
  6. Which rules this guide assumes

Short answer

In standard Kalah, with 4 seeds in every pit, the best way to open is to play the pit that is exactly 4 steps from your store. That is the 3rd pit if you count from your left, and the 4th pit if you count from your store. Its last seed lands in your store, so you get an extra turn. Computers have also shown that the player who moves first wins with perfect play, by 8 seeds under standard rules.

Why that pit works

In Kalah you sow counter-clockwise, dropping one seed in each pit and in your own store, but never in your opponent's store. If your last seed lands in your own store, you move again.

Start with 4 seeds in every pit. A pit ends its sowing in your store only when the number of seeds in it equals the number of steps to the store. With 4 seeds, that means the pit exactly 4 steps away.

Number your six pits from the end farthest from your store:

Pit counted from your left123456
Pit counted from your store6th5th4th3rd2nd1st
Steps to your store654321

Pit 3 (from the left) is 4 steps from the store. Its 4 seeds go into pits 4, 5, 6 and then your store. The extra turn is free: you have not given your opponent a move yet.

Check it on your own board. Sow the seeds from the pit you picked and see whether the last one falls in the store. If it does, you counted correctly.

Why guides disagree about the "third pit"

You will see "start with the third pit" in some guides and "the fourth pit" in others. Both can be right, because they count from opposite ends. The third pit from your left is the same pit as the fourth pit from your store. A guide that says "third from your store" has miscounted: that pit has 3 steps to go, so a 4-seed pit there overshoots and drops a seed in your opponent's side.

What to play after the extra turn

After the first move the board is no longer the starting position, so there is no single fixed line to memorise. The sensible thing to check each time is whether another pit now ends exactly in your store, and whether a capture is on offer. You can test the positions you reach with the Mancala move calculator, which shows where every pit's last seed lands. The calculator searches a limited number of moves ahead, so from the opening position its ranking can differ from the solved result described below; it is a search, not the full solution.

Does going first win?

The Kalah page on Wikipedia reports that the 3-, 4-, 5- and 6-seed versions of Kalah have been solved, and in each of them the starting player wins with perfect play. For the standard rules with 6 pits and 4 seeds, the first player wins by 8 seeds.

Two details matter if you compare numbers between sites.

  • The number depends on the capture rule. Under the "empty capture" variant, where you capture even when the opposite pit is empty, the first player wins by 10 instead. That is a different rule set, so a "win by 10" you see elsewhere is not the standard figure.
  • The same Wikipedia page gives a table of results for each possible opening under standard rules. That section of the page is marked as lacking citations, so treat the figures as reported, not as something we checked ourselves. It lists playing pit 3 and then pit 6 in the same turn as the strongest start, a win by 8. It also lists opening with pit 1 as a loss by 14 and pit 2 as a loss by 10 against perfect play. In that table, playing pit 6 on its own wins by 4, so pit 3 is not the only reasonable start.

Because standard Kalah favours whoever moves first, Todd W. Neller and Taylor C. Neller of Gettysburg College proposed FairKalah, which uses slightly different starting positions, moved by one or two seeds, that are draws with perfect play. Their page uses the empty capture rule, so its numbers do not apply to standard Kalah.

Perfect play is a computer standard. Against a human, the first move is a good habit, not a guarantee.

Habits that follow from the rules

These come straight from how sowing works, not from any study.

  • Look for pits whose seed count equals their distance to your store. Each one is an extra turn.
  • Before you move, check whether your last seed will land in an empty pit on your side. If the pit opposite has seeds, that is a capture. If the pit opposite is empty, there is no capture under standard rules.
  • Watch your opponent's empty pits too. A seed landing there on their turn can capture from your side.
  • Count the seeds left on each side as the board empties. The game ends when one side has no seeds, so the endgame is mostly counting.

Which rules this guide assumes

Everything above is standard Kalah as the app implements it: 6 pits a side, 4 seeds a pit, counter-clockwise sowing that skips the opponent's store, an extra turn when your last seed lands in your store, and a capture only when the opposite pit has seeds. The solved result assumes the standard end rule, where the player who still has seeds on their side keeps them. If you play with a different leftover-seeds rule, the final scores can differ. Our full rules guide covers each rule and its variants.

Mancala - Seedwise

Classic Kalah Mancala against six computer rivals, with a new puzzle every day.

Get it on Google Play

Free, with an occasional full-screen ad after a game, never during play. Mancala Plus is a one-time purchase that removes full-screen ads and adds unlimited hints, a free second try at the daily puzzle, the full puzzle archive and a supporter board.

Mancala - Seedwise plays standard Kalah against six computer rivals, so you can practise your opening against the Teacher rival. Two people can also play on one phone. It has no online multiplayer.

Sources

  1. Kalah - Wikipedia
  2. FairKalah - Todd W. Neller and Taylor C. Neller, Gettysburg College

Search the site